A STUDY ON THE RIGHTS OF STATELESS CHILDREN

 

AUTHORED BY - KISHORE CHANDURU K R[1],

 

 

ABSTRACT

Statelessness is a condition that occurs when a person is not considered a citizen by any country. Stateless children are often born into this precarious situation due to a complex combination of factors, including discriminatory laws, conflict, and administrative deficiencies. This article highlights the plight of stateless children and emphasizes the importance of addressing this issue at a global level. Statelessness is a global and largely overlooked problem that affects millions of children around the world. Stateless children are born into unstable and vulnerable environments and are denied basic rights such as education, healthcare and citizenship. This article examines the concept of statelessness, its causes and consequences, and the urgent need for international action to protect and support marginalized children.

 

Introduction

Children's rights are universal and inalienable, but for millions of children around the world, statelessness poses a serious threat to their fundamental rights. Statelessness occurs when an individual is not considered a citizen by any country, leaving them without the protections and privileges afforded to citizenship. This issue disproportionately affects children and addressing the link between children's rights and statelessness is vital to ensuring a better future for these vulnerable people. It seems you are asking about children's rights. Children have internationally recognized rights and these are often referred to as “children's rights” or “children's rights”. These rights aim to protect and promote the welfare of children and ensure that they are treated with dignity and respect.  One of the most famous documents describing children's rights is the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), adopted in 1989[2]. The CRC sets out a comprehensive framework of children's rights, including the right to life, the right to life, education, the right to health care, the right to protection from abuse and exploitation, and the right to have a voice in matters that concern them, among others. Children's rights are based on the principle that children are individuals with their own needs, interests and opinions and they should be treated as such. These rights are vital to ensuring that children grow up in a safe, nurturing environment and have the opportunity to reach their full potential. It should be noted that specific rights and protections for children may vary between countries, but there is broad international consensus on the basic principles set out in the CRC. Around the world, efforts are being made to ensure that children's rights are respected and protected.

 

The Magnitude of the Problem

Estimates suggest there are at least 3.9 million stateless children worldwide, although the actual number is likely much higher. These children face many challenges, including limited access to education, health care and social services as well as vulnerability to exploitation, discrimination and violence force. The consequences of statelessness can last a lifetime, leaving these children at a disadvantage.

 

Root Causes of Child Statelessness

Child statelessness is a complex issue with multiple root causes. These root causes vary from one region to another and are often interconnected. Here are some of the primary root causes for child statelessness

 

1. Discriminatory Laws:

Nationality laws that discriminate on the basis of ethnicity, religion or sex can leave a child stateless from the moment he or she is born. In some countries, nationality laws are discriminatory on the basis of ethnic origin, religion, sex or race. Nationality laws can deny citizenship to certain groups, and when a child is born to a parent who is discriminated against, the child is at risk of being stateless[3].

1. Birth Registration:

Not registering your child's birth is one of the biggest causes of statelessness. A lot of kids are born in poor communities or in conflict areas where it's hard or impossible to get registered. Birth registration is the first step in creating your child's legal name and citizenship. In a lot of countries, kids who are born in poor areas, in conflict areas, or to people who don't have legal rights may not be registered when they're born. Without proper paperwork, these kids are at risk of being stateless.

1. Migration and Displacement:

If the child is born to parents who are stateless and have to leave their countries, they are at risk of being stateless themselves, which makes the situation even worse.

1. Arbitrary Revocation of Citizenship:

In certain circumstances, citizenship may be revoked without prior notification, resulting in children being stateless. Similarly, certain individuals or societies may have their citizenship revoked without prior notice, resulting in the children being stateless, without legal protection or entitlements.

1. Conflicts and Displacement:

Statelessness can occur as a result of armed conflicts, civil wars and forced displacement, particularly when a person is forced to leave their homeland. Statelessness can also be experienced by children born to parents who have been displaced, as they may face difficulties in obtaining citizenship or birth registration.

1. State Succession and Changes:

When states experience a political transition, such as a merger, division, or succession, nationals living in those regions may find their citizenship challenged. Furthermore, children born in such situations may face statelessness if the citizenship of the child is unclear.

1. Gender Discrimination:

In some countries, the implementation of nationality legislation may result in the inability of female individuals to transfer their citizenship to their offspring. This can lead to the adoption of a child without the right to transfer the mother's nationality, thus creating a situation of statelessness[4].

1. Lack of Awareness and Access:

Many families, particularly those located in less affluent or remote areas, are unaware of the significance of registering for birth or meeting the necessary legal requirements to acquire citizenship for their children. Additionally, lack of access to governmental services and inadequate documentation can be a hindrance.

1. Administrative Barriers:

Administrative barriers, such as complex paperwork, language barriers, or financial constraints, can prevent families from registering their children’s birth or from filing for citizenship[5].

 

In order to combat child statelessness, it is essential to address the root causes through legislative reform, educational activities, improved birth registration processes, and international cooperation. It is also essential to ensure that each child has the right to be recognised as the citizen of the country of which they are citizens, and that they are able to enjoy their fundamental entitlements and immunities.

 

Statelessness among children in India:

This is a complex and challenging issue, although precise numbers are difficult to ascertain. Several factors contribute to statelessness among children in India:

 

1. Discriminatory Nationality Laws:

India's nationality laws are governed by the Citizenship Act of 1955, which has undergone several amendments over time. Nevertheless, the Act still contains loopholes and discriminatory provisions that may result in statelessness, particularly among marginalized communities.

1. Lack of Birth Registration:

Birth registration is a fundamental factor in determining a child's legal status and citizenship. In India, birth registration is subject to numerous difficulties, especially in remote or disadvantaged areas. This can result in statelessness, as a child without a birth certificate may find it difficult to demonstrate his nationality.

1. Migration and Displacement:

India harbours a substantial populace of refugees, asylum seekers, and internally displaced individuals. Offspring born to these groups may encounter challenges in obtaining citizenship or registration of birth, leading to a state of statelessness.

1. Gender Discrimination:

India's nationality legislation has historically been unfavourable to women, thus making it challenging for mothers to transfer citizenship to their offspring. In certain circumstances, children born of an Indian mother and a foreign father may encounter difficulties in obtaining Indian citizenship.

1. State Succession and Changes:

Political changes and border disputes can lead to uncertainties regarding nationality for individuals living in affected regions, potentially resulting in statelessness for children.

1. Lack of Awareness and Documentation:

Many families, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds, may not be cognizant of the significance of birth registration and the legal requirements for citizenship acquisition for their children. Access to government services and cumbersome documentation procedures can exacerbate this problem.

 

Statelessness in India has been the focus of numerous efforts to combat it. In 2019, the Citizenship Amendment Act was introduced with the aim of expediting the process of acquiring Indian citizenship for certain religious minorities from neighbouring countries. Despite this, the law has been met with criticism and fears of discrimination.

 

Impact on Child Rights

Children have inherent rights that must be protected and maintained to ensure their welfare and development. These rights serve as the foundation for children to grow up in a caring and supportive environment where they can reach their full potential. All children are the future of the world, so it is the responsibility of governments, parents, communities and society as a whole to maintain and protect these rights[6].

 

1. Right to Identity:

Statelessness denies children their right to a legal identity, making it challenging to access essential services, such as education and healthcare.

1. Right to Education:

Stateless children often face barriers to education, as they lack the necessary documentation, which hampers their development and future prospects.

1. Right to Protection:

Without a nationality, these children are at increased risk of exploitation, trafficking, and child labour.

1. Right to Family Life:

Stateless children may be separated from their families due to the legal limbo they find themselves in.

Impact of statelessness on children:

Statelessness has a serious and detrimental impact on children, affecting many aspects of their lives. Some of the main effects of statelessness on children include:

 

1. Restricted access to education:

Educational opportunities for stateless children are often hampered by a lack of proper identification. This may result in you being denied admission to an educational institution or access to educational resources. As a result, lack of education hinders stateless children's intellectual and social development and limits their future prospects.

1. Lack of access to health care:

Statelessness can result in a lack of access to health services. If children do not have citizenship, they may not be eligible for government-sponsored health insurance or health programs, putting them at risk of contracting preventable diseases and not receiving adequate medical care.

1. Protection issues:

Stateless children may be at increased risk of exploitation, trafficking, child labour exploitation, or forced child marriage. Additionally, legal protections and guarantees of civil rights may be stripped away, increasing vulnerability to abuse and mistreatment[7].

1. Restrictions on freedom of movement:

Statelessness can have a significant impact on a child's ability to move freely. Stateless children are prevented from traveling within and outside their countries of origin and may be unable to attend school, find employment, or reunite with their families.

1. Family separation: 4,444 stateless children may experience family separation due to differences in the nationality of their parents or legal guardians. Such separation can have a negative impact on children's emotional and psychological well-being and affect their sense of belonging and security.
2. Legal Vulnerability:

Stateless children can be detained or arrested for even minor crimes based on their legal status. Additionally, they are often denied access to legal representation and may face indefinite detention or deportation.

1. Denial of citizenship rights:

Stateless children are denied basic citizenship rights, including the right to participate in electoral processes, run for political office, or receive social assistance programs. and are deprived of their rights. This leads to a perpetual cycle of marginalization and exclusion[8].

1. Psychological Impact:

The anxiety and prejudice associated with statelessness can have a significant psychological impact on children. They can experience anxiety, feelings of isolation and lack of belonging, which can impact on their mental health.

1. Economic Disadvantage:

Statelessness can also have a negative impact on an individual's economic situation. This is because children often do not have access to formal employment opportunities and may be forced into unsupervised and exploitative work to make ends meet.

1. Barriers to legal identity[9]:

Stateless children lack a legal identity and are therefore unable to assert their rights in legal matters, including issues related to inheritance, property, or family disputes. It will be difficult.

 

International Efforts to Address Child Statelessness:

Several international conventions and initiatives aim to combat child statelessness. Global partnerships and organizations such as UNICEF and Save the Children work to protect and defend the rights of stateless children.

 

Combating child statelessness is a global concern, with various international initiatives and organizations working to combat this issue[10]. These initiatives aim to prevent and reduce child statelessness around the world. Here are some of the major international efforts to combat child statelessness:

 

1. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR):

UNHCR launched a special campaign called “#IBelong” in 2014, with the aim of ending statelessness by 2024. The campaign focuses on identifying stateless persons and providing them with citizenship or alternative legal status[11].

 

1. United Nations Conventions:

The 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons and the 1961 Convention for the Reduction of Statelessness provide a legal framework for dealing with statelessness. These conventions establish principles and guidelines for the prevention and reduction of statelessness, including provisions regarding children.

1. UNICEF (United Nations Children's Fund):

UNICEF works to protect and promote the rights of children around the world. They advocate for every child's right to a legal identity, including citizenship, and support efforts to ensure that children are registered at birth.

1. Global Campaign for Equal Citizenship Rights:

This campaign, supported by various organizations, is a campaign against discriminatory civil rights that prevent mothers from passing on citizenship rights to their children on an equal footing with fathers. The purpose is to reform the law.

1. European Network on Statelessness:

This network is committed to combating statelessness in Europe and has advocated for policy changes in various European countries to prevent and reduce child statelessness[12].

1. NGOs and civil society organizations:

Many nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and civil society organizations focus on statelessness, advocate for the rights of stateless children, and provide legal access to affected individuals and families. We provide support.

1. International Organization for Migration (IOM):

IOM is committed to addressing the issue of statelessness in the context of migration and displacement. They work to ensure that immigrants, including children, have access to legal identification.

1. Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR):

In the Americas, the IACHR has taken action to combat statelessness by making recommendations to States and promoting legal reform to prevent child statelessness.

1. United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child:

This Committee monitors the implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child and provides guidance to States on preventing and combating child statelessness.

 

These international efforts include advocacy, research, capacity building and policy development to raise awareness of child statelessness, promote legal reform and protect the rights of stateless children. The common goal of these organizations and initiatives is to ensure that all children, regardless of their birth circumstances, enjoy a nationality and the rights and protections that come with it.

 

National Law:

Combating child statelessness in India requires comprehensive legal reforms, improved birth registration systems, and strengthened awareness campaigns. We also need a rights-based approach that prioritizes the protection and welfare of all children, regardless of their nationality or country of birth. International organizations, civil society and the Indian government must work together to ensure that India's stateless children are recognized, protected and given the opportunities they deserve.

 

The Government of India has taken several steps to address the problem of stateless children and improve their situation. It's important to note that things may have changed since then, and we recommend staying up to date with the latest developments. Some of the key measures taken by the Government of India are listed below[13].

 

1. Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019:

The Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 aims to enable certain minority religious groups (Hindus) to obtain Indian citizenship. (Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis, Christians) from Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Pakistan who entered India before 31 December 2014. Although this law was intended to address the concerns of specific stateless persons, it raised controversy and concerns about the impact on other groups and potential discrimination.

1. National Register of Citizens (NRC):

The Government of India has launched the National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam to identify and remove illegal immigrants. This process involved verifying individuals' citizenship status, resulting in some individuals being declared stateless. Although the NRC was initially targeted at Assam, there were discussions about its implementation in other parts of India, leading to widespread debate and concerns.

1. Birth Registration Initiatives:

The government has undertaken various initiatives to facilitate birth registration and improve documentation for children. These initiatives aim to ensure that all children are registered at birth, an important step in preventing statelessness.

1. Legal Aid and Advocacy:

NGOs and civil society organizations in India address issues related to statelessness and provide legal aid to people at risk of statelessness, including children. These organizations work to defend the rights of stateless persons and raise awareness of this issue.

1. International Conventions:

India is not a party to her 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons or her 1961 Convention for the Reduction of Statelessness. However, we have been working with international organizations such as UNHCR to address concerns about statelessness and explore possible solutions.

 

It is important to recognize that addressing statelessness is a complex issue with social, political and legal dimensions. The Indian government's move has received both support and criticism, and the situation continues to evolve. For the latest information on government efforts to combat child statelessness in India, we recommend contacting official government sources and relevant organizations working in this field.

 

Recommendations for Action

Statelessness is a deeply worrying issue that deprives children of basic rights and opportunities. It perpetuates cycles of poverty, vulnerability and exclusion. Combating child statelessness requires governments, international organizations and Civil society needs to work together. Every child has the right to the opportunity to live a dignified and fulfilling life, and this starts with securing their legal identity and citizenship rights.

 

Protecting the rights of stateless children is critical to ensuring their welfare and development. There are several steps and measures that can be taken to protect the rights of stateless children.

 

1. Law Amendments:

Review and amend the Nationality and Citizenship Laws to eliminate discriminatory provisions and ensure children's right to citizenship at birth. Ensures laws that allow children to acquire the citizenship of their country of birth even if their parents are stateless or hold another nationality.

1. Birth Registration:

Implement an accessible and comprehensive birth registration system to ensure that all children, including stateless children, are registered at birth. Conduct awareness campaigns to inform communities about the importance of birth registration and simplify the registration process.

1. Access to education:

Ensure equal access to education for stateless children, regardless of their nationality or country of birth. Remove all obstructions such as: B. Documentation requirements that prevent stateless children from enrolling in schools.

1. Access to Health Care:

Ensure access to health services for all children, regardless of nationality or statelessness. Develop health programs for stateless children, especially vulnerable children.

1. Protection from Exploitation:

Strengthens legal protections for stateless children to prevent them from being exposed to exploitation, trafficking, or child labour. Establish mechanisms to identify and provide assistance to stateless children at risk of exploitation.

1. Legal identification and documentation:

Ensure that stateless children are provided with identification and legal recognition, including birth certificates and citizenship certificates. Streamlines the process for stateless children to obtain documentation.

1. Family Unity:

Prevent family separation due to statelessness by allowing stateless children to be reunited with their parents or guardians, even if they live in another country.

1. Education and Advocacy:

Conduct educational campaigns to inform the public, government officials, and communities about the rights and vulnerabilities of stateless children. Advocate for the rights of stateless children through civil society organizations and international organizations.

1. International Cooperation:

Collaborate with international organizations, neighboring countries, and relevant stakeholders to address transnational issues related to stateless children. Participate in international conferences and agreements aimed at preventing and mitigating statelessness.

1. Monitoring and Reporting:

Establish mechanisms for monitoring and reporting on the situation of stateless children, including data collection and analysis to assess progress and identify areas for improvement.

1.  Legal Aid:

Provides legal aid and assistance to stateless children and their families, enabling them to navigate complex legal processes and assert their rights.

1. Capacity Development:

Train government officials, health care providers, educators, and other relevant professionals on the rights and needs of stateless children.

 

Protecting the rights of stateless children requires a comprehensive, rights-based approach that includes legal reform, awareness-raising and international cooperation. It is important to recognize that all children, stateless or not, have the right to legal identity, citizenship and access to essential services.

 

Conclusion

Child statelessness is a global crisis that deprives millions of children of basic rights and opportunities. It is the responsibility of governments, international organizations and civil society to work together to eliminate the causes of child statelessness and protect the rights of these vulnerable people. Addressing this issue comprehensively will ensure that every child, regardless of nationality or place of origin, has the opportunity to live a full and dignified life.

 

In summary, protecting the rights of stateless children is not only a matter of justice but also a fundamental necessity for the welfare and development of children. Stateless children face numerous challenges and vulnerabilities that can hinder their access to education, health care, and protection from exploitation. A multifaceted approach is essential to address these issues and protect the rights of stateless children.

 

This approach should include legal reforms to eliminate discriminatory laws, accessible birth registration systems, and equal access to education and health care. Furthermore, raising awareness about the rights and vulnerabilities of stateless children is crucial for communities and authorities to understand their responsibility to protect these children.

 

International cooperation is also important because stateless people often cross national borders. Cooperative efforts with neighbouring countries and cooperation with international organizations can help address the complexities of transnational statelessness.

 

To protect the rights of stateless children, governments, civil society organizations and the international community must work together to build a world in which all children, regardless of their nationality or country of birth, enjoy all rights. It is essential that the rights and opportunities they receive; By taking these steps, we can build a future where statelessness is a thing of the past and the rights of every child are upheld and protected.

 

---

[1] Assistant Professor,VELS INSTITUTE OF SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND ADVANCED STUDIES, (VISTAS)

[2] https://www.unicef.org/child-rights-convention/convention-text-childrens-version (22.09.2023)

[3] https://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/wp-content/uploads/IBELONG_Minority-Children-and-Statelessness.pdf (29.09.2023)

[4] https://goodfaithmedia.org/gender-discrimination-root-cause-of-stateless-children/ (27.09.2023)

[5] https://www.statelessness.eu/updates/blog/states-root-cause-statelessness (26.09.2023)

[6] https://www.smilefoundationindia.org/child-rights/ (01.10.2023)

[7] https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=96841 (26.09.2023)

[8] https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/AD1039168.pdf (02.10.2023)

[9] https://www.humanium.org/en/stateless-invisible/ (29.09.2023)

[10] https://www.getinthepicture.org/sites/default/files/resources/Good%20Practices%20Paper%20-%20Action%202%20Ensuring%20that%20no%20child%20is%20born%20stateless.pdf (03.10.2023)

[11] https://www.unhcr.org/id/wp-content/uploads/sites/42/2017/05/Protecting-the-Rights-of-Stateless-People-ENGLISH-FINAL.pdf (03.10.2023)

[12] https://rm.coe.int/cdcj-2022-12-statelessness-report-of-the-international-conference-and-/1680a74cfa (02.10.2023)

[13] https://nludelhi.ac.in/download/publication/2015/august/India%20and%20the%20Challenge%20of%20Stateless-A%20Review%20of%20the%20Legal%20Framework%20relating%20to%20Nationality.pdf (22.09.2023)